Toggle Nav
My Cart
Toggle Nav

Homemade peanut butter eggs recipe

Our Homemade peanut butter eggs recipe requires only 4 ingredients to make.


Have you ever wondered how to make chocolate peanut butter eggs? Our recipe makes a creamy peanut butter filling that isn’t overly sweet. Sure, you can buy filled eggs already made in the grocery store, but nothing beats the taste of homemade!

Things you’ll need:

Homemade Peanut Butter Eggs Recipe:

Step 1:

Using a hand mixer or a stand mixer, mix together the peanut butter, melted butter, and fondant sugar, until it forms a dough. Wrap or cover with plastic wrap until you are ready to use it*.

*Store the filling in the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks after making it.

Step 2:

Melt one pound of Merckens candy coatings in the microwave 30 seconds at a time, stirring in between intervals, See how to melt Merckens candy coatings here.

Step 3:

Spoon chocolate and fill each egg cavity of the candy mold. Once filled, place in the refrigerator for 1 minute.

Step 4:

How to make a chocolate shell for homemade peanut butter eggs 
Over a piece of parchment, turn the candy mold over and dump out the excess melted chocolate, leaving a chocolate shell in the candy mold. Use a spatula to scrape away any chocolate that’s on the edge of the mold. Place in the refrigerator for one minute, or until hardened. 
 Chocolate shells in an egg candy mold


Step 5: 

Peanut butter filling inside of chocolate shell in egg candy mold.

Roll a ball of peanut butter candy filling in the palm of your hands and press it down into the molded shell.

Step 6:

Spooning chocolate over the peanut butter filling inside of the egg candy mold
Once all your shells are filled with peanut butter filling, top with melted chocolate and spread it out to the edges. Place in the refrigerator for about three minutes or until hard.
Peanut butter filled chocolate eggs unmolded

 Unmold and ENJOY!

Try using a variety of molds to make chocolate eggs in different styles and sizes!

Chocolate eggs with peanut butter filling unmolded in different sizes.